Butterfinger Protein Shake

I’m guessing you have some chocolate protein powder hiding in the back of your pantry. Perhaps it found a spot on top of your fridge? There ya go!

Pull it out, dust it off, and get ready to enjoy those morning protein shakes again because this Butterfinger Protein Shake will knock your socks off!

Butterfinger Protein Shake

Surprisingly, there are zero Butterfingers harmed in this delicious shake.

The combination of chocolate protein powder, protein rich peanut butter, and a little bit of sugar free butterscotch pudding mix makes a guilt free shake that tastes exactly like a liquified butterfinger candy bar.

Your welcome!

Butterfinger Protein Shake

Some days I’ll mix it with almond milk, some days I mix it with regular milk… either way, it still tastes incredible. In fact, I look forward to my filling breakfast treat every day! Keeps me full until lunch time, which is a definite bonus for this full time food blogger!

I use the Shakeology Chocolate Protein Powder, but I’m sure any chocolate protein powder would give you the same results.

Make sure you don’t miss a thing! Follow I Wash You Dry here:

Butterfinger Protein Shake

Butterfinger Protein Shake


  • 1 cup milk (any kind will work)
  • 1 cup cold water
  • 1 cup ice cubes
  • 1 scoop chocolate protein powder
  • 1 (large) tbsp peanut butter
  • 1 tbsp sugar free Butterscotch instant pudding mix


  1. Combine all ingredients in a blender and process until well blended (about 1 minute).
  2. Enjoy right away.

Notes from Shawn

Use more or less water according to your preference. Less water will make it thicker and more will thin it out.

Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by ZipList Recipe Plugin


  1. Oh man, I love butterfingers. Love that this shake doesn’t harm any, LOL!!!Looks awesome girl :)

  2. Shawn … Oh, this is so great and I found our protein powder and dust it off. Now, need to make a quick trip to the market to get Butterfingers. Would you believe that we can’t find a Butterfinger anywhere around this ole’ house … :-) But, I do have a question about the instant pudding – what flavor do we use? I’m thinking chocolate, but just not sure. Thank you for the recipe … you are wonderful!

    • Hi Joicio, you’ll want to use the butterscotch pudding mix (I can’t believe I forgot to put that in the recipe, but I updated it just now), and you don’t actually put any butterfingers in the shake, so no need to purchase any of those! Unless, of course, you just want to eat a butterfinger! ;)

  3. Um, I want this.

  4. Tried this today!! It’s great!

  5. I am SO MAKING THIS TOMORROW for breakfast. #yum

  6. Where do you buy that brand protein powder?

  7. Try using slim fast powder. Their chocolate flavor is the best ever

  8. What a great way to use protein powder in a recipe! Chocolate in itself is a flavor straight from heaven and the fact that you have combined it with PB and butterscotch pudding is just tempting me to chug this shake down.

Speak Your Mind


Current ye@r *